Death to the Desktop! Long Live the Cloud!

I don't think that Cloud Computing will ever completely replace regular desktops (think: professional 3D, gaming, and many, many other processor and resource-intensive tasks. Those just aren't meant to be run remotely) And also, if I want to use my netbook while on the road (read: no internet access whatsoever - and I am not buying a 3G dongle for that -) I cannot do it with a ChromeOS-like machine. With a regular OS I can do many many things without 'net. (Apart from web browsing, chatting,researching and IM'ing,i can do everything without net, really)
So my opinion? "Traditional" operating systems are here to stay. Period.

What a horrible idea!

Should we all trust our private lives and business to some nefarious unkown and well hidden cloud in the sky? In this environment you have no control over your computing experience, no control over your content, no freedom to choose what you want or dont want. You just blindly accept whatever the cloud gods put on offer for you to consume.

I cant even believe I am reading this from Ken Hess no less. Shame!

No thanks. I prefer to be free and keep my information and programs under my control, on my system. If you want to be a slave and put yourself under someone elses control, good for you.

Just a suggestion, but you might want to begin your computing education with CS-001. I think that would help you to understand basics like input/output, screen, keyboard, etc. before moving onto more complex subjects? "The Cloud" is just another marketing buzzword created by senile old people like Steve Ballmer.

An internet connection is not available all the time and everywhere one might want or need it; even if it were available, it might not be fast enough for one's needs; even if it were fast enough, there would be hardly enough space for everyone's terabytes of data; and, most importantly, even if there were space enough, only a complete fool would leave all of his or her data under the control of someone else. And the foolishness of such an idea is all the more evident as nowadays it is so easy to keep and carry huge amounts of data in small, portable devices. And as to the 'virus-riddled' thing, have you ever heard about Linux?

I think you guys are getting this all wrong. I'm not saying that I want this to happen but I think it will happen. I think that within the next couple of years, Internet access will be everywhere that you have cell phone access, XM radio access, etc. Satellites will provide that Internet everywhere access for our gadgets.
Your "operating system" if you want to call it that, will exist in the "cloud." Yes, I know that the "cloud" is marketing but people understand the concept so I have to use it. When in Rome, you know?
And, I'm afraid, that regardless of how much we all love it, the traditional desktop operating system's days are numbered.
To see the future, check out http://g.ho.st
Sure there will be things you can do in an unconnected state using something like portableapps.com.

I think you guys are getting this all wrong. I'm not saying that I want this to happen but I think it will happen. I think that within the next couple of years, Internet access will be everywhere that you have cell phone access, XM radio access, etc. Satellites will provide that Internet everywhere access for our gadgets.
Your "operating system" if you want to call it that, will exist in the "cloud." Yes, I know that the "cloud" is marketing but people understand the concept so I have to use it. When in Rome, you know?
And, I'm afraid, that regardless of how much we all love it, the traditional desktop operating system's days are numbered.
To see the future, check out http://g.ho.st
Sure there will be things you can do in an unconnected state using something like portableapps.com.

> [khess:]
> I think you guys are getting this all wrong. I'm not saying that I want this > to happen but I think it will happen.

Then you have to explain why exactly you said that this imagined replacement of the desktop by cloud computing 'sounds like good news to me', and why exactly you said that 'It's time for the traditional desktop operating system to go away', and why exactly you said that 'I've waited for a server-centric world for several years now'.

You are now trying to distance yourself from a previously held stance, which is ok -- but please don't do so saying that others 'got you wrong' or distorting the meaning if your own previous words.

Others did not get you wrong -- your readers are not as stupid as you might think -- it's just that you lacked the straightforwardness either to say that your view changed or to defend it.

@jsp722

You're right, perhaps a poor choice of words. I guess the real fallout is that by writing this some people feel that I have some responsibility in causing it to happen and I don't, of course.

Without supporting or opposing cloud computing and cloud operating and software services, the statement that desktop computers will always exist for resource intensive applications may not be true.

The primary factor preventing centralized, networked systems from providing resource intensive services is data transfer width and rate. With modern operating systems residing in as much as two gigabytes of memory constantly at any given nanosecond, it would take at least approximately two and a half hours to transfer a single nanosecond slice of the entire operating system on a typical low end broadband connection. That assumes an ideal that the maximum bandwidth per second is used. That isn't always the case.

Now certainly redesign would reduce the amount of data transferred and how often data needed to be transferred, but the point is that tasks such as graphics rendering and bulk data processing over network are limited by data transfer rates.

However, as data transfer rates and bandwidths increase, this barrier becomes less of a factor. All ready, locally networked mainframes can provide centralized resource intensive services to node computers. If data transfer services improve sufficiently then it may be feasible in the future to provide resource intensive services over a cloud environment.