Member Avatar for Salem

So I've seen two (possibly more) threads that end with the phrase "let's discuss" and an exclamation mark of over-enthusiasm (which is ironic, since it's low post count drive-by accounts posting this stuff).

The preambles are well written, but meaningless pith.

It's such an odd way of closing out a post that it stinks of having AI behind it. One post would have been curious, but two posts (and counting) is looking like a pattern.

What is clear though is that whoever replies is expected to do all the heavy lifting if the topic was to be answered properly.

The examples:

https://www.daniweb.com/digital-media/threads/543256/exploring-the-future-of-audio-technology-innovations-and-trends
https://www.daniweb.com/digital-media/ui-ux-design/threads/543236/best-ways-to-print-a-high-quality-book-cover

  • 3 Contributors
  • 9 Replies
  • 50 Views
  • 5 Days Discussion Span
  • Latest Post Latest Post by Reverend Jim
Member Avatar for Dani

I agree that they might be AI generated, or at least have the help of AI. Sometimes it's hard to tell, and I always want to exercise extreme caution and not delete or infract a post unless I'm 100% confident. I have a bit of a migraine right now, so I have to put a little more thought into whether these 2 posts should be deleted when my head is a bit clearer.

However, I would not discount a new topic because the goal is that whoever replies is expected to do all of the heavy lifting. That's the case in the majority of Q&A topics. Also, what would happen if there was a "Let's discuss!" added to the end of this topic or even this one or this one?

Member Avatar for Reverend Jim

I have a problem with people who start posts about a topic with "let's discuss", but don't actually start the discussion. I have a friend (?) in Toronto who, especially during election season (which seems to be always these days), asking for my opinion on things without ever offering one of her own. I got tired of putting in the effort and getting none in return. IMO posters who are asking for my opinion (as opposed to advice or help) should first offer one of their own. Hopefully an informed opinion.

Member Avatar for Dani

I disagree with that sentiment when it comes to a Q&A forum such as DaniWeb. The very premise of the site is that people ask questions. Quite often, uninformed questions. Sometimes those questions are just asking for your informed opinion as an expert in your field or as someone more informed than they are at the topic at hand. Other people take the time to answer, because the things they have to say go on to help far more than just the question asker or discussion starter, and sometimes spark interesting discussions and perspectives.

I fail to see the distinction between asking for an opinion versus a suggestion versus any other form of help or assistance.

However, where I agree with you is when the ask is strictly AI generated without being backed by any person’s actual struggle, perspective, confusion, etc.

Member Avatar for Reverend Jim

And I disagree with that. The post I was referring to was

In this thread, let's dive into the exciting advancements in the world of audio technology. From spatial audio to AI-driven sound systems, the audio landscape is evolving rapidly. Share your thoughts on the latest innovations, your favorite audio gadgets, or how new tech is shaping your listening experience. Whether you're an audiophile or just someone who loves great sound, let's discuss what's next in audio!

Clearly the OP was starting a discussion, not seeking help with a problem. Please reread my post where I clearly said

posters who are asking for my opinion (as opposed to advice or help)

I will clarify "opinion" as an opinion on a discussion topic as opposed to an opinion on a software or hardware recommendation.

Edited by Reverend Jim
Member Avatar for Dani

I fail to see the distinction between asking for an opinion versus a suggestion versus any other form of help or assistance.

I understand that you see a distinction when the OP is trying to start a discussion versus asking for advice or help.

However, I don’t understand why you make that distinction in a Q&A discussion forum.

Member Avatar for Reverend Jim
  1. I thought we didn't have "forums" anymore.
  2. Perhaps the OP posted in the wrong place.
  3. Regardless, it was clearly a discussion and not a question.

It's moot since the thread has been deleted.

Edited by Reverend Jim
Member Avatar for Dani

I have a bit of a migraine right now, so I have to put a little more thought into whether these 2 posts should be deleted when my head is a bit clearer.

Unfortunately, I ended up in the ER from an unrelenting migraine that hasn’t let up for 6 days, and is not responding to any medication.

I don’t mean to drop the ball on this thread.

commented: I hope you get better soon. +0
Member Avatar for Dani

Today is day one trillion of this still unrelenting headache. FINALLY, a diagnosis! I have shingles. Feeling hopeful to begin treatment and start feeling better.

commented: I hope you have an easy and fast recovery +0
Member Avatar for Reverend Jim

I've had close relatives who had that but I don't recall headaches as a symptom. I hope I never get it (I can't get the vaccine because it's a live vaccine). Good luck with recovery now that you have a diagnosis.

Be a part of the DaniWeb community

We're a friendly, industry-focused community of developers, IT pros, digital marketers, and technology enthusiasts meeting, networking, learning, and sharing knowledge.